How to Choose and Recognize a High-Quality Extra Virgin Olive Oil
- mirabellagaia
- Apr 19
- 2 min read
Extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) isn’t just a cooking ingredient—it’s a cornerstone of the Mediterranean diet, a symbol of culture and craftsmanship, and a superfood packed with health benefits. But not all olive oils are created equal. In a market full of options, how do you make sure you're choosing the real deal?
Here’s a guide to help you spot authentic, high-quality EVOO and make every drizzle count.
Start with the Label
Read carefully. A trustworthy bottle should clearly state:
“Extra Virgin Olive Oil” – This means the oil was extracted mechanically, without heat or chemicals, and meets strict standards for flavor and acidity (less than 0.8%).
Country of origin – Look for oils produced and bottled in the same country. “Product of Italy” should mean it was both harvested and bottled in Italy—not just packaged there.
Harvest date – Olive oil doesn’t age well. Choose a harvest from within the last 12–18 months for best flavor and nutrition.
Cultivar(s) and single origin or estate bottled – The more transparent the brand is, the more likely you’re getting quality.
Use Your Senses
Good EVOO is alive—it speaks through aroma and flavor.
Smell it: A fresh oil should have an aroma that reminds you of green olives, freshly cut grass, artichoke, herbs, or even green apple.
Taste it: The flavor should be vibrant, with a balance of fruitiness, bitterness, and pepperiness. A slight tingling or burning in the back of your throat is a good sign—those are polyphenols, powerful antioxidants that are part of what makes EVOO so healthy.
If the oil tastes flat, greasy, musty, or rancid, it’s past its prime—or wasn’t quality to begin with.
Pay Attention to Packaging
Light and heat are EVOO’s enemies.
Choose bottles made of dark glass or opaque tins, which protect the oil from harmful UV rays.
Avoid clear bottles or plastic containers, which accelerate oxidation.
A tightly sealed cap is essential to keep air out.
Know How to Store It
Even the best oil can deteriorate quickly if not stored properly.
Keep it in a cool, dark place, away from stoves or windows.
Don’t store it in the fridge—it can solidify and lose aroma.
Use it within a few months of opening to enjoy peak freshness.
Trace the Source When Possible
The best olive oils often come from small, transparent producers who care deeply about the land and their trees.
Whenever possible, choose oils from brands that share details about the harvest, milling process, region, and variety of olives used. These producers often follow sustainable practices and put quality over quantity.
At Terragaia, for example, we currently work with a trusted Sicilian producer whose oil is rich, vibrant, and full of Mediterranean soul. As we grow, we aim to bring you more oils from other Italian regions—but always with the same values.
Comments